white clock, white plate, black knife and fork, grey backgound, intermittant fasting

Are Calorie Restriction and Intermittent Fasting the Keys to Longevity?

  • Introduction: Diet and Longevity
  • Molecular Causes of Aging and the Effects of Calorie Restriction
  • Study Design and Key Findings
  • CR and IF Extend Lifespan
  • Surprising Results on Weight Loss and Lifespan
  • Calorie Reduction and Metabolism
  • Implications for Humans
  • Conclusions
  • References

In the quest for a longer, healthier life, many have turned their attention to diet, specifically the impact of calorie restriction (CR) and intermittent fasting (IF). These two popular approaches promise not only weight loss but potentially the key to extending lifespan and delaying the onset of age-related diseases. Backed by decades of research, recent findings from the Jackson Laboratory (JAX) have shed new light on how these dietary patterns affect longevity—highlighting surprising insights into the relationship between body weight, metabolic health, and aging. This blog explores the ground-breaking study and its implications for those looking to optimise their health and extend their life. Could eating less actually help you live longer? Let’s find out.

Introduction: Diet and Longevity


For centuries, the idea that food impacts both health and lifespan has intrigued scientists and everyday individuals alike. The connection between diet and longevity is not just rooted in folklore or anecdotal evidence; it's a subject extensively explored by modern science. Research shows that certain dietary approaches—such as intermittent fasting (IF) and calorie restriction (CR)—can influence aging processes, making these strategies popular choices for those looking to extend not just lifespan but also "healthspan," the period of life free from chronic disease.

Laboratory studies, particularly on animals, have long suggested that those eating less or fasting periodically tend to live longer. This is frequently attributed to a combination of weight loss, improved metabolic function, and reduced oxidative damage at the cellular level. These outcomes are often framed as mechanisms to combat the aging process, reducing the onset of diseases such as cancer, diabetes, and heart conditions.

Now, researchers at the Jackson Laboratory (JAX) have conducted one of the most comprehensive studies on CR and IF, involving nearly 1,000 mice. Published recently in the journal Nature, this study sheds new light on how these dietary patterns affect longevity and overall health. Surprisingly, the study found that the mice with the longest lifespan were not the ones who lost the most weight but those who maintained the most stable body mass, even while reducing caloric intake. This finding adds a nuanced layer to our understanding of the intricate relationship between food, weight, and lifespan.


Molecular Causes of Aging and the Effects of Calorie Restriction


Aging is a complex biological process driven by a multitude of molecular changes. Some of the primary causes of aging include DNA damage accumulation, oxidative stress, inflammation, and telomere shortening. Over time, these factors lead to cellular and tissue dysfunction, which manifest as age-related diseases such as Alzheimer's, heart disease, and various cancers. The more these processes accumulate, the faster we age.

Calorie restriction, which involves reducing caloric intake without malnutrition, has emerged as one of the most effective strategies for combating these molecular drivers of aging. Research in animals, from yeast to primates, has demonstrated that CR can extend lifespan. The mechanisms by which CR works are not fully understood but appear to involve several pathways linked to longevity.

One key pathway is the reduction of reactive oxygen species (ROS). These harmful by-products of metabolism cause oxidative stress, which damages cells over time. CR lowers ROS levels, reducing oxidative damage and thus slowing aging at the cellular level. Additionally, CR has been shown to activate sirtuins, proteins that play a significant role in regulating cellular health, aging, and metabolic function. Sirtuins help cells adapt to stress and improve their survival, which contributes to longer life.

Autophagy, another crucial process stimulated by CR, enhances cellular repair by breaking down and recycling damaged components. This process helps maintain the overall health of cells, delaying the onset of dysfunction that leads to aging. By also reducing inflammation, CR can decrease chronic diseases associated with age, further promoting a healthier, longer life. Overall, the molecular benefits of CR are profound, making it a powerful tool for delaying aging and extending health span.


Study Design and Key Findings


Studying longevity is a challenge in human populations due to the long lifespan of humans and the difficulty of controlling variables over decades. This is why animal models, such as mice, are often used in longevity research. The JAX study utilised a diverse population of 960 genetically unique female mice to explore how CR and IF affect both lifespan and health. This approach, using an "outbred" mouse population, stands in contrast to the typical use of genetically identical animals, which often limits the generalisability of findings. By incorporating genetic diversity, the researchers aimed to better mimic the variability found in human populations.

The mice were divided into five groups with distinct dietary interventions:

  • Ad libitum (AL): Mice had unlimited access to food and could eat as much as they wanted.
  • 20% Calorie Restriction (CR): Mice consumed 80% of their normal calorie intake.
  • 40% Calorie Restriction (CR): Mice consumed only 60% of their usual caloric intake.
  • Intermittent Fasting (IF) 1 day per week: Mice fasted for one full day each week.
  • Intermittent Fasting (IF) 2 days per week: Mice fasted two days each week.

Over the course of the study, the health and lifespans of the mice were monitored. Remarkably, the study found that CR and IF both extended the lifespan of the mice, with a clear dose-dependent relationship: the more calories reduced, the longer the mice lived on average. Mice on the 40% CR diet had the longest average lifespan, followed by the 20% CR group, and then the intermittent fasters. Unsurprisingly, mice with unrestricted access to food had the shortest lifespan.

This study's design allowed researchers to explore how genetic differences affect the response to dietary interventions, adding an additional layer of complexity. Such a genetically diverse model means the results are more likely to reflect real-world outcomes, making this research particularly relevant for human health.


CR and IF Extend Lifespan


The JAX study reinforced previous findings that both calorie restriction and intermittent fasting can extend lifespan. However, what stood out was the extent to which genetic factors influenced the outcomes. While CR and IF showed clear benefits in terms of longevity, individual responses to these dietary interventions varied significantly.

For example, the group of mice on a 40% CR diet lived the longest on average, yet there were substantial differences in lifespan among individual mice in this group. Some mice thrived on this reduced diet, while others did not fare as well. The mice that lived the longest were those that lost the least weight during the calorie reduction. This suggests that simply cutting calories is not the sole factor in extending life; how the body responds to calorie reduction, potentially influenced by genetic makeup, plays a critical role.

Intermittent fasting also extended lifespan, though not as dramatically as CR. The results showed that fasting one or two days per week was beneficial, but not as effective as continuous calorie reduction. This suggests that while IF can offer health benefits, it may not be as potent as a more sustained reduction in caloric intake. Nevertheless, IF has been shown in other studies to improve metabolic health, reduce inflammation, and promote autophagy, all of which are beneficial for longevity.

These findings support the idea that a moderate, sustained reduction in calorie intake—combined with genetic resilience—may be the best strategy for promoting a long, healthy life. However, individual variability means that these diets may not work equally well for everyone.


Surprising Results on Weight Loss and Lifespan


One of the most surprising findings from the JAX study was the relationship between weight loss and lifespan. Contrary to popular belief, the mice that lost the most weight during the 40% CR diet did not live the longest. In fact, those that maintained a more stable body weight—despite reduced calorie intake—had the greatest lifespan extension.

This finding challenges the common notion that weight loss is inherently linked to longevity. Instead, it suggests that maintaining physiological health and resilience, rather than extreme weight reduction, may be more important for extending life. Mice that lost significant amounts of weight often exhibited lower energy levels, weaker immune systems, and poorer overall health, leading to shorter lifespans compared to their counterparts that maintained a more balanced body weight.

This result points to the importance of balance. While reducing calorie intake can have benefits, it may be detrimental if it leads to excessive weight loss or undermines immune health. The researchers suggest that genetic factors could play a significant role in how individuals respond to caloric restriction. In humans, this could mean that some individuals might thrive on a calorie-restricted diet, while others may not experience the same benefits.

In addition to maintaining body weight, the study found that mice with stronger immune systems and better overall health under stress conditions (like prolonged calorie restriction) lived longer. This indicates that resilience—both at the genetic and physiological level—may be key to a longer life, rather than simply losing weight or cutting calories.


Calorie Reduction and Metabolism

Another fascinating aspect of the JAX study was its findings on metabolism. While calorie restriction led to improvements in metabolic health—such as lower body fat, improved insulin sensitivity, and reduced markers of inflammation—these changes were not directly responsible for the lifespan extension observed in the study.

The researchers discovered that although calorie reduction improved body composition and metabolic markers, these factors alone did not explain the increase in longevity. Instead, they found that genetic resilience, immune system strength, and stress resistance played a more significant role in determining how long the mice lived.

This is an important distinction because it suggests that while metabolic health is crucial for overall well-being, it may not be the sole determinant of lifespan. Calorie restriction's ability to lower metabolic rates—often viewed as a sign of improved longevity—may not guarantee a longer life if the body's other systems, such as the immune system, are not equally resilient.

This finding has important implications for how we approach dietary interventions in humans. While improving metabolic health is undoubtedly beneficial for reducing the risk of chronic diseases like diabetes and heart disease, it may not be enough to extend lifespan on its own. Instead, a holistic approach that includes maintaining immune health, managing stress, and perhaps even tailoring dietary interventions to individual genetic profiles may be the key to maximising longevity.


Implications for Humans


What does this all mean for humans? While mice are often used as a model for studying human biology, the direct application of these findings to human health requires caution. Nevertheless, the study offers several insights that could be relevant for those looking to extend their lifespan through dietary interventions.

First, the study highlights the potential benefits of both calorie restriction and intermittent fasting for extending health span and potentially lifespan. However, it also underscores the importance of individual variability. Just as the mice in the study responded differently to the diets based on their genetic makeup, humans are likely to experience varying degrees of success with CR and IF.

Second, the finding that weight loss is not necessarily linked to longer life challenges a common misconception. While maintaining a healthy weight is important for overall health, extreme weight loss—especially if it compromises immune function—may not be beneficial for longevity. Instead, focusing on balanced nutrition, maintaining muscle mass, and supporting immune health may be more important than simply cutting calories.

Lastly, the study's emphasis on genetic resilience and immune system strength suggests that future research may focus on personalised approaches to diet and aging. Rather than adopting a one-size-fits-all approach, individuals may benefit from dietary interventions tailored to their unique genetic profiles and physiological responses. This could involve genetic testing to identify the best dietary strategy for each person, optimising their chance for a longer, healthier life.


Conclusion

The findings from this ground-breaking study underscore the complexity of aging and the multifaceted role that diet plays in the process. While calorie restriction and intermittent fasting offer promising strategies for extending life, the results also show that these interventions are not a guarantee for everyone. Genetic resilience, immune health, and the body's ability to adapt to stress are all critical factors in determining lifespan.

For those looking to optimise their health and longevity, the key takeaway is that moderation and balance are essential. Rather than focusing solely on cutting calories or losing weight, individuals should aim to maintain overall health through balanced nutrition, regular physical activity, and stress management. In the future, personalised dietary approaches based on genetic information may offer even more targeted ways to promote longevity and well-being.


References

Back to blog